My women’s group has enjoyed many dinners here. The staff is so kind friendly & very attentive. And the food is delicious; portions are extremely generous! We always take home our leftovers, enough for 2 or 3 people! There is ample parking, . I’d highly recommend this restaurant, family friendly & consistently great choices, very reasonable too😊
R C
-
October 14, 2024
This was one of our favorite Greek restaurants to go to. However, the food is always hit or miss.
You will have one amazing day, and then the next couple times will be absolutely horrible. Friends of ours refuse to come back due to the inconsistency.
After giving up and not coming here a few years, we gave it another try. The french toast was absolutely perfect.
This time, the french toast was basically just dry bread, nothing French toast about it. We asked our waitress and she said she would redo it. It came back even drier and she never bothered to ask if it was better.
The other time our complaints were the toast was cold with massive amounts of butter that couldn't melt (see pic). French toast was cold and hard to chew. Pancakes were just alright. The home fries were good though.
Some waitresses are super nice, friendly, personable, and attentive.
Ed Vidra
-
March 15, 2025
Great local diner with tremendous service. Food is known to always be good. Lots of locals eat here. We ordered steak and eggs. Blueberry pancakes traditional breakfast. Everything delicious. A keeper
Erica Enders
-
February 03, 2025
This was my first time at this establishment and unfortunately will also be my last. We decided to dine here because it came highly recommended by a friend of mine. We got seated pretty immediately even though they were super busy, which was nice however it took 20 minutes for us to place our order. Seeing as it didn’t take the table next to us that long after ordering for them to receive their food we didn’t think that was a big deal. However 10 minutes after placing our order we were advised that the sourdough sandwich special they advertise when you first walk in they didn’t have, so they asked if I wanted it on a different bread or something else, so I asked for a menu (again, it was our first time here). No less than 30 seconds after it was dropped off, the server is coming back to see what I wanted. I politely handed her the menu back and said I didn’t want anything. How can I decide what else I wanted from a large menu if you don’t even give me a few minutes to look at it. So we paid for my beverage as well as my mothers meal and left. I won’t be back.
Lisa Spina
-
December 06, 2024
The family came in last minute and needed a table for 16 people. Within minutes they had tables set up for all of us. The service was amazing Good job to the cooks in the back the food came out piping hot fresh and our waitress did not miss a beat with all the condiments and drinks. Great job!!
Keep up the good work. That's what makes customers keep coming back. Thank you
Our Address
3901 Sheridan Dr, Amherst, NY 14226, USA
Claim Listing: Sheridan Family Restaurant
Please Login or Register an Account to Claim Listing
My women’s group has enjoyed many dinners here. The staff is so kind friendly & very attentive. And the food is delicious; portions are extremely generous! We always take home our leftovers, enough for 2 or 3 people! There is ample parking, . I’d highly recommend this restaurant, family friendly & consistently great choices, very reasonable too😊
This was one of our favorite Greek restaurants to go to. However, the food is always hit or miss. You will have one amazing day, and then the next couple times will be absolutely horrible. Friends of ours refuse to come back due to the inconsistency. After giving up and not coming here a few years, we gave it another try. The french toast was absolutely perfect. This time, the french toast was basically just dry bread, nothing French toast about it. We asked our waitress and she said she would redo it. It came back even drier and she never bothered to ask if it was better. The other time our complaints were the toast was cold with massive amounts of butter that couldn't melt (see pic). French toast was cold and hard to chew. Pancakes were just alright. The home fries were good though. Some waitresses are super nice, friendly, personable, and attentive.
Great local diner with tremendous service. Food is known to always be good. Lots of locals eat here. We ordered steak and eggs. Blueberry pancakes traditional breakfast. Everything delicious. A keeper
This was my first time at this establishment and unfortunately will also be my last. We decided to dine here because it came highly recommended by a friend of mine. We got seated pretty immediately even though they were super busy, which was nice however it took 20 minutes for us to place our order. Seeing as it didn’t take the table next to us that long after ordering for them to receive their food we didn’t think that was a big deal. However 10 minutes after placing our order we were advised that the sourdough sandwich special they advertise when you first walk in they didn’t have, so they asked if I wanted it on a different bread or something else, so I asked for a menu (again, it was our first time here). No less than 30 seconds after it was dropped off, the server is coming back to see what I wanted. I politely handed her the menu back and said I didn’t want anything. How can I decide what else I wanted from a large menu if you don’t even give me a few minutes to look at it. So we paid for my beverage as well as my mothers meal and left. I won’t be back.
The family came in last minute and needed a table for 16 people. Within minutes they had tables set up for all of us. The service was amazing Good job to the cooks in the back the food came out piping hot fresh and our waitress did not miss a beat with all the condiments and drinks. Great job!! Keep up the good work. That's what makes customers keep coming back. Thank you